Announcement
#1 2006-07-30 08:03:05
- MichaelAGates
- Supreme Member

- From: Ohio
- Registered: 2006-05-01
- Website
Movies Wear Military Uniforms Wrong on Purpose?
There is a story going around saying that in the movies, military uniforms are worn with insignia wrong on purpose, because it is illegal to wear military uniforms in a movie.
Is it true? Is it illegal to wear a military uniform in a movie?
The simple answer is "no".
United States law allows military uniforms to be worn by an actor in a theatrical or motion-picture production. So the story that uniforms cannot be legally worn in the movies, is just an urban legend.
----
United States Code Title 10 > Subtitle A > Part II > Chapter 45
ยง 772. When wearing by persons not on active duty authorized
(f) While portraying a member of the Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marine Corps, an actor in a theatrical or motion-picture production may wear the uniform of that armed force if the portrayal does not tend to discredit that armed force.
----
Now I have seen many movies that get the military uniforms and insignia correct. However, I have seen many movies were the military uniforms and insignia were less than correct. Why do you think that is, since the law allows military uniforms to be worn in the movies?
AllMilitary - Where Military Means Family
Offline
#2 2006-07-30 12:33:39
- JPW
- Executive Member
- Registered: 2006-05-04
- Posts: 2461
Hollywood isn't filled with ex-military to point out errors. some movies get consultants some don't. some consultants are idiots some are not.
some believe "hellywood" as in Hell wood does it wrong on purpose to insult our military so they are made to look foolish and weakend to help bring about the dustruction of America which they hate.
Personally I think it is choice 1 but there might be some robo Reublicans here so I thought I should give both options.
My opinions expressed are all well reasoned and insightful needless to say they are my own crazy ramblings...
Resident Paradox
Offline
#3 2007-12-04 12:38:16
- PoppinFresh
- Member
- Registered: 2007-11-17
- Posts: 68
I think this rumor may have been fueld by a story attributed to Lee Ermy, the actor who plays the Drill Instructor in "Full Metal Jacket" and the host of "Mail Call", about how he refused to wear a rank he didn't earn, so he intentionally wore something else incorrectly on his uniform at the same time. I don't know if the story is true or not.
I think most of the errors in military uniforms (and customs and courtesies) in movies and TV are due to ignorance on the part of the movie crews. What looks right to someone who has no idea of what the regulations are might look completly wrong to someone who has worn the uniform for a few years.
Another reason might be an attempt to have something look correct to the majority of the intended audience of the movie - they may want something to look right to most of the audience, but most of the people who make movies probably don't know any better themselves.
A really good example of a movie that was made without a military consultant is "Basic", starring Samuel L. Jackson, Sharon Stone, and John Travolta. I've only seen the movie once, but if I remember correctly, they had a lot of errors that made the movie difficult to watch: one character was a female Ranger and Samuel L. Jackson's character changed rank (up and down) as the movie went on, but he'd be yelling in someone's face while that person was wearing a higher rank than his own.
I don't agree with the notion that they do it on purpose to insult the military. Although there are people involved in making movies who disagree with national policy and who don't care for the military, having an actor wear a uniform improperly isn't very insulting if it's a subtle error.
Offline

Answer a few questions and in minutes find out what VA benefits you qualify for. Don't wait any longer to take advantage of the Veteran benefits you have earned, including VA Home Loans.
#4 2007-12-04 13:19:32
- Clovis Lee Booker
- Supreme Member

- Registered: 2006-12-13
- Posts: 3805
When I was an extra in a motion picture I walked over to the people filming and suggested they correct items worn on the uniforms before they started filming and was told to shut the hell up. They had a man dressed in a khaki uniform, all fine and dandy, but they added a yellow stripe to the trouser's leg and had the others wearing Mexican Army rank badges on what were supposed to be U.S. Army uniforms. Western Costume on Melrose used to rent uniforms and they'd try to get it right, but L.A. Uniform Exchange also on Melrose wanted to unload some white dress shoes and sold them to be worn with khaki uniforms when brown shoes would have been worn, I told the owner of the store and he said he knew, but the film company did not know and it was about making sales of slow moving items, period! How many actors will get their hair cut short for a film that the story takes place in boot camp or basic training? I saw a film of John Travolta as a Chief Warrant Officer dressing down a Lieutenant General. The officer who's rank went up and down with a silver oak leaf one scene and a silver eagle next scene. The Lieutenant General flucuated between three stars and one star. Perhaps they were meant to be "flash-backs?"
Offline
#5 2007-12-04 13:36:50
- Captain Kirk
- Top Gun Member

- Registered: 2007-10-05
- Posts: 9254
JPW wrote:
Hollywood isn't filled with ex-military to point out errors. some movies get consultants some don't. some consultants are idiots some are not.
some believe "hellywood" as in Hell wood does it wrong on purpose to insult our military so they are made to look foolish and weakend to help bring about the dustruction of America which they hate.
Personally I think it is choice 1 but there might be some robo Reublicans here so I thought I should give both options.
JPW,
robo here , been missing you JPW.
The movie studios often hire military advisors to make sure they are doing things right.
I lived near the Studios for several years.
Worked with many studio people.
They strive for realisum but I don't think they put the emphasis on having everything correct that they once did.
It is up to the Producer and director how much emphasis they put on it.
Offline
#6 2007-12-04 16:15:16
- Garrysr
- Administrator

- Registered: 2007-10-07
My wife hates to watch military movies or tv with me, as I tend to notice the mistakes. Really hate the "Sta-puft Marshmallow man" beret look.
I tried to wear mine right, as I respected the ones who earned them in the past.
"I take pride in what I do and it doesn't matter who it is helping as long as it helps, if only a little."
Fallen soldier quote, inscribed on the War on Terror memorial at the Iowa Veterans Cemetery.
Offline
#7 2008-06-03 10:53:36
- RobbSmith
- Member

- Registered: 2008-06-03
- Posts: 96
Garrysr wrote:
My wife hates to watch military movies or tv with me, as I tend to notice the mistakes. Really hate the "Sta-puft Marshmallow man" beret look.
I tried to wear mine right, as I respected the ones who earned them in the past.
My wife hates me at movie time also!...lol
Robb Smith (US Army, 1SG, Retired)
Offline

